I'm not. I'm referencing the paper - not some hypothetical abstract word problem. Imagine walking into a room, where the pieces are slowly morphing from staid Staunton structures into amorphous blobs of lava lamp Cthulhu nightmares. If a locomotive steam train from Denver passes within 15 meters of the room, how many passengers paid for the tickets using a cashier's check?
Nobody's arguing that humans never take logical shortcuts or that those shortcuts can cause us to make errors.
Some of the rebuttals in this thread are ridiculous. Like what if I forced you to stare at the surface of the sun followed by waterboarding for several hours, and then asked you to look at a 1000 different chess boards. Are you sure you wouldn't make a mistake?
In the paper the various VLLMs are asked to double-check which still didn't make a difference. The argument is more along the lines that VLLMs (and multimodal LLMs) aren't really thinking in the same way that humans do.
And if you REALLY need an example albeit a bit tangential - try this one out. Ask any SOTA (multimodal or otherwise) model such as gpt-image-1, Kontext, Imagen4, etc. for a five-leaf cover. It'll get it about 50% of the time.
Now go and ask any kindergartener for the same thing.
Nobody's arguing that humans never take logical shortcuts or that those shortcuts can cause us to make errors.
Some of the rebuttals in this thread are ridiculous. Like what if I forced you to stare at the surface of the sun followed by waterboarding for several hours, and then asked you to look at a 1000 different chess boards. Are you sure you wouldn't make a mistake?
In the paper the various VLLMs are asked to double-check which still didn't make a difference. The argument is more along the lines that VLLMs (and multimodal LLMs) aren't really thinking in the same way that humans do.
And if you REALLY need an example albeit a bit tangential - try this one out. Ask any SOTA (multimodal or otherwise) model such as gpt-image-1, Kontext, Imagen4, etc. for a five-leaf cover. It'll get it about 50% of the time.
Now go and ask any kindergartener for the same thing.