Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> begging letter

> begging message

I keep seeing this in many online spaces and for the life of me, I just can't understand how asking for money in exchange for value (journalism in this case) is considered begging.

Seriously, this [1] is their ask, can you (or anyone else) show me exactly which part of it is begging?

[1] http://www.niemanlab.org/images/guardian-membership-ask.jpg



It's not so much the message as its persistence, timing and size. It shows up every time and takes up half the screen. It would also be nice if the reader was given some time to read actual content before being blasted with the message again. Feels like one of those many many sites that immediately ask you to fill out a feedback form before you've even browsed anything. If it's not a beg, it's most certainly a nag.


> its persistence, timing and size.

> It would also be nice if the reader was given some time to read actual content before being blasted with the message again.

What do you mean ? It's an inline box that always appears after the article. It's not a popup, it doesn't hinder navigation, it doesn't even have position:fixed so you can just scroll by it if you want. I don't think they could be nicer about it if they tried.


You're mistaken. There are two separate messages - a popover that appears at the bottom of the screen every time you browse a page (whether it be the front page, an article, etc.) AND the more innocuous inline text at the end of every article that you mention.


Ah, sorry. I never saw such a popover. Probably due to adblock.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: