Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | grauniad's commentslogin

Block hackernews. Block reddit.


> purely based on search terms.

I got the impression from the blog post that a son may have clicked on links possibly relating to how bombs are made. Perhaps the FBI were monitoring who clicks on those links, and then checked for further search activity etc.

I'm not suggesting any of this is warranted obviously (Terrorism isn't a real threat at all), but it does look like it was more than 'just' search terms.


Maybe he should have asked. Or gone about it in a legal way.

Breaking the law, is breaking the law. However noble your intent.


Jesus Christ, you're serious here?

He broke the law. Then he committed suicide. I don't think there's much debate to be had about where any blame lies.


larrys, you haven't disputed any of my points other than telling me that I'm wrong, which makes sense since you're unwilling to use your real HN account.

> He broke the law.

Was the law that was broken make sense? Was the response to a victimless crime appropriate?

> Then he committed suicide.

You're acting like people dealing with a serious mental illness for years can easily make the same mundane choices that people without mental illness do everyday. It's more complicated than that.


I'm not larrys. All I'm saying is that he clearly had his own demons, and his own problems. He decided to break the law, knowing what the result would be. Then he decided to end his own life. A sad tale, but the law is the law.


Yeah whatever.

> A sad tale, but the law is the law.

Some laws are unjust, ridiculous, or both. There's also something called "the spirit of the law" as well.


Wait until you're perhaps older, with children to feed, bills to pay. maybe employees or shareholders that need to see a return.


How is it really ironic?

The Guardian is extremely sociliast in its reporting. That's just not popular. You're not going to make any profit with that political viewpoint. (Although you'll certainly be popular on Reddit, the BBC, and other left leaning communities).

To make money, you need to be center / center right to appeal to most people. That's why newspapers like "The Sun" and "Daily Mail" absolutely dwarf "The Gruaniad" in readership.

If anything, to me it smacks of hypocracy rather than irony. It would be like a campaign setup to promote vegetarianism, bankrolled by a side venture selling beef burgers.


Socialist only by American standards (and, possibly, by the standards of certain Tories who still think of the US as a former British colony). By European standards, the Guardian is a fairly typical center-left newspaper. If you want to look at an actual socialist newspaper in the UK, try the Morning Star [1].

The relative popularity of the Sun and the Daily Mail is best explained by Jim Hacker and friends: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DGscoaUWW2M&t=1m0s

In other words, a classical broadsheet vs. tabloid situation. Politics doesn't sell as well as gossip and T&A.

[1] http://www.morningstaronline.co.uk/


Ach, come on, the Guardian's incredibly left-wing. Or at least was until recently (less than 5 years).

When I used to buy papers a few times a week, I rotated the Guardian, The Independent and the Telegraph.

If you went outside the news articles the Guardian was foaming at its mouth, agenda crazy leftie. The editors, opinions and letters pages were filled with rubbish. Far more than the Telegraph was politely right wing.

Perhaps they've toned it down since focusing online, but though I don't read the site I still come across op pieces linked in various places that show otherwise.


The Guardian is a broadsheet, not a tabloid. If you want compare it something on the right use the Times or the Telegraph.

The tabloid equivalent of a left newspaper (though the terms make much less sense since the tabloids aren't nearly as political) would be the Daily Mirror, and it more than holds its own in the circulation wars.


They're not exactly socialist, they're centre left. They just look socialist in comparison to stuff like the Telegraph.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: